Slimming with skin cream? Fat chance, says agency
Washington, January 8, 2014
People putting their faith in miracle cures to shed unwanted pounds are likely to be disappointed, US regulators said in announcing settlements with four firms accused of falsely advertising weight-loss products such as skin creams.
The Federal Trade Commission won agreements from L'Occitane; Sensa Products; HCG Diet Direct; and LeanSpa. The settlements required them to drop unsubstantiated claims from their ads and, in some cases, return money to consumers.
The FTC also urged media outlets to scrutinise advertisements more carefully to avoid publishing potentially misleading ads, noting that some of the advertisements for the products - from food supplements to skin creams - appeared in mainstream publications.
The commission provided guidance for publishers and broadcasters on how to screen weight-loss claims in advertisements.
The FTC's action, codenamed "Operation Failed Resolution," was timed to coincide with the vows to lose weight so often made, and quickly abandoned, in January.
Jessica Rich, director of the FTC's Bureau of Consumer Protection, warned that the only slim element of the products is their chance of success. "Resolutions to lose weight are easy to make but hard to keep. And the chances of being successful just by sprinkling something on your food, rubbing cream on your thighs, or using a supplement are slim to none," Rich said.
One agreement was with Sensa, which said that its powder sprinkled on food would cause weight loss and peddled it on television infomercials, magazine advertisements and online ads.
The company said the powder "is clinically proven to cause substantial weight loss without dieting or exercise, averaging 30 pounds in six months," the FTC said in a court filing. In contrast, a study of the product by a Sensa company executive found that users lost an average of 5.6 pounds over six months, the FTC said in its court filing.
A one-month supply of Sensa's powder cost $59.00, plus shipping and handling, the FTC said. Sensa agreed to return $26.5 million to consumers, the commission said.
Sensa said in a statement that the company had admitted no wrongdoing and that the FTC did not challenge the product's safety.
"Sensa is incorporating changes to its advertising to comply with the FTC's consent order and continues to support the brand with new advertising and marketing materials," the company said.
In a separate court filing, the FTC said L'Occitane sold two skin creams that promised "clinically proven slimming effectiveness" and would "visibly reduce the appearance of cellulite." L'Occitane agreed to pay $450,000 to reimburse customers.
There was no evidence that the cream slimmed thighs or reduced cellulite, the FTC said.
L'Occitane said it had cooperated fully with the commission, and had implemented "even more rigorous policies and procedures that will guide future clinical testing and ensure that our marketing and advertising comply with FTC regulations and guidelines."
A third company, HCG Diet Direct, sold liquid drops that it said contained a hormone produced by human placenta that would help people lose weight. Under a settlement, the company agreed to an order requiring it to pay $3.2 million. The judgment was suspended because the company could not pay it.
The FTC also reached a settlement with LeanSpa, which had used fake news websites to advertise the acai berry as a weight-loss miracle product until the company was shut down by
the FTC and Connecticut attorney general's office in 2011.
Boris Mizhen, a LeanSpa executive, will surrender $7 million in cash and property while his wife, who did not participate in the scheme, will surrender $300,000.
Attempts to reach the other two companies by telephone, email or by Twitter were not successful. - Reuters